Dear Copy Editors, (the comma is intentional)
Guess what I googled. Guess what returned 287 results.
- Prefix magazine: "...TV on the Radio heads back to the future on Dear Science,. (The comma is intentional.)"
- New York Times: "On Sept. 23 TV on the Radio follows its widely praised 2006 album, “Return to Cookie Mountain,” with a magnificent third album, “Dear Science,” (the comma is part of the title)."
- Metromix LA: "Metromix has been given access to the new TV on the Radio album Dear Science, (the comma is part of the title)..."
- New York magazine: Dear Science, (the comma is, ridiculously, part of the title)
- USA Today: " TV on the Radio's follow-up to their 2006 album, Return to Cookie Mountain, will hit shelves on Sept. 23 and is called Dear Science,. (The comma is intentional.)"
- Paste: "TV on the Radio's much-anticipated Dear Science, (the comma is theirs)..."
- Pitchfork: "Dear Science, is due September 23 on Interscope and yes, the comma is indeed part of the title."
- Stereogum: "TV On The Radio's forthcoming return from Cookie Mountain, titled Dear Science, (comma included, thinking its epistolary)." [Ed. note—congrats on "epistolary" but you fucked up on "it's"]
OKAY EVERYONE LOOK CLOSELY AT THE ALBUM COVER:
Good one! (Nice independent thinking and investigative work.)
Posted by: Paul | September 10, 2008 at 08:20 PM
Yeah but what about the spine?
Posted by: sv | September 11, 2008 at 06:31 PM
If there is a comma on the spine then the copy editors should rise up and point out the inconsistency, like the anal nerds they (we) are.
Posted by: scott pgwp | September 11, 2008 at 06:56 PM